SolisReach
← Journal
Web Design & Development6 min read

Forms are the most under-designed part of most websites

Written by the SolisReach team

Forms get less design attention than almost any other part of a typical website, and it's an odd pattern once you actually notice it, because a form is often the exact moment a visitor is closest to converting into a real lead or a real customer. We audit forms specifically and separately on nearly every project now, precisely because they're so consistently under-designed relative to how much they genuinely matter to the business.

A homepage hero gets careful attention, thoughtful copywriting, real strategic thought about layout and hierarchy. A contact form three clicks later often gets whatever a template happened to include by default, unstyled error messages, no clear indication of exactly what's actually required, no real thought given to how it genuinely feels to fill out from a real visitor's actual perspective.

Why this gap exists in the first place

Forms feel purely functional, almost like plumbing, something that simply has to exist and technically work rather than something that deserves genuine design consideration in its own right. This framing misses something important: a form is where a visitor's actual intent gets converted into a real, usable business outcome, and friction at exactly this specific point directly costs conversions that everything else on the site worked hard to earn.

We push clients to think about form design with the same real seriousness as any other conversion-critical element on the page, because it genuinely deserves that level of attention, even though it doesn't photograph as impressively in a portfolio case study as a striking hero section does.

The specific mistakes we find most often

Unclear indication of which fields are actually required versus optional, leaving a visitor guessing about what's genuinely necessary before they can successfully submit. Generic, unhelpful error messages that say something like "invalid input" without specifying clearly what's actually wrong or how to fix it, forcing a frustrated visitor to guess repeatedly at what the form actually wants from them.

Too many fields requested upfront, well beyond what's genuinely needed for the very next step in an ongoing relationship, based on an instinct to gather as much information as possible right away rather than starting with a small, low-friction ask and building the relationship naturally from there.

What genuinely good form design actually looks like

Real-time, specific validation that tells a visitor immediately and clearly what's wrong with their specific input, rather than only surfacing a vague error after a full, failed submission attempt. Clear, honest labeling of every required field, with optional fields explicitly marked as optional so nobody has to guess about what's genuinely necessary.

A field order that follows a natural, logical sequence, with the easiest, lowest-friction fields presented first to build momentum, and any more sensitive or effortful fields placed later, once a visitor has already invested some real time and effort into completing the earlier, easier parts of the form.

Why mobile form design deserves genuinely separate attention

A form that's perfectly reasonable to fill out on a desktop with a full keyboard can be genuinely painful on a phone, particularly if input types aren't properly set to trigger the correct on-screen keyboard, a numeric keypad for a phone number field, an email-optimized keyboard for an email field, and so on for each relevant field type.

We test every form specifically on mobile, filling it out ourselves by hand exactly as a real visitor would, because this is precisely where a huge share of real friction actually lives for a huge share of real visitors, given how much traffic now genuinely arrives on mobile devices.

A form that's perfectly reasonable to fill out on a desktop with a full keyboard can be genuinely painful on a phone, particularly if input types aren't properly set to trigger the correct on-screen keyboard, a numeric keypad for a phone number field, an email-optimized keyboard for an email field, and so on for each relevant field type.

The business case for investing real design effort in forms

We've measured meaningful conversion rate improvements from form redesigns alone, changes that required no other adjustments anywhere else on the surrounding page, purely from reducing friction at exactly this one specific conversion point. This is one of the clearest, most directly measurable returns available in web design work, and it's still one of the most commonly overlooked opportunities across the client sites we regularly audit.

We present this specific case to clients directly, with real before-and-after numbers from past projects, because a concrete, measurable conversion lift is a far more persuasive argument for investing real design time in what might otherwise seem like a purely mundane, unglamorous part of the site.

What we do differently in our own form design process

We wireframe forms with the same deliberate care we apply to any other important page section, considering field order, visual grouping, and error state handling explicitly and specifically, rather than accepting whatever a form-building tool happens to provide by default without any real customization.

We also test every form with a real, unfamiliar user before calling any project finished, watching directly for hesitation, confusion, or any genuine friction that we, as the people who already know exactly what the form is asking for, would likely never notice or catch on our own.

A quick way to audit your own form right now

Fill out your own contact or signup form, on your phone, as if you were a genuinely new visitor with no prior context. Note every moment of hesitation, every unclear field, every error message that didn't tell you exactly what to fix. This exercise takes about five minutes and consistently surfaces real, fixable problems that are easy to miss when you already know exactly what the form is asking for.

We do this exact exercise on every client's existing form before proposing any redesign, because it's the fastest, most direct way to build real, specific empathy for a genuinely unfamiliar visitor's actual experience, rather than relying only on abstract best-practice principles applied generically without any concrete evidence behind them.

A form is often the single most consequential moment on an entire site, the exact point where a visitor's genuine intent either converts into a real business outcome or quietly gets lost to unnecessary, avoidable friction along the way.

We'd rather spend real, deliberate design time here than anywhere else that photographs more impressively in a portfolio but ultimately matters less to the actual business outcome the entire site was originally built to serve in the first place.

If your own site's forms haven't been specifically reviewed in a while, that's very likely one of the highest-leverage places to look next, before investing further effort anywhere else on the page that ultimately matters less to the bottom line.

Start a project

Want this applied to your site?

We run a Core Web Vitals and SEO audit before quoting any performance marketing engagement, and we're happy to share what we'd find on yours.